Ask us about our lifetime warranty

Should I Repair Or Replace My Shower?

Every homeowner will have to decide whether to repair or replace their shower at some point. There are many factors to consider before making this decision. The cost of repairs, the age of the shower, the condition of the plumbing, and personal preferences are all important considerations.

In this blog post, we will provide you with a comprehensive guide to help you decide whether to repair or replace your shower. We will also discuss whether or not to do the replacement on your own or hire a professional.

Shower Repair vs Shower Replacement

Pros and Cons of Shower Repair

Shower repair involves fixing specific parts of a shower that have malfunctioned or are worn out, leaving the surrounding structure intact. The biggest advantage of shower repair is its cost-effectiveness. Shower repair is often the cheaper alternative option and can extend the lifespan of your shower system.

However, there are instances where repair might not be the best solution. For example, if the damage is extensive, repairing your shower may only serve to temporarily solve the problem. You may end up having to make further costly repairs down the line. Furthermore, if your shower is outdated, repairing it may not be effective in updating its appearance or enhancing its functionality.

Pros and Cons of Shower Replacement

When you opt for a shower replacement, all the components of your old shower are removed and replaced with new ones. One of the significant advantages of shower replacement is that you get to customize the entire system according to your preferences. Also, replacement offers a fresh and modern design, enhancing the value and look of your bathroom.

However, shower replacement can be more expensive than repair, so cost is a major factor to consider. Another disadvantage of shower replacement is that it can take considerably longer to undertake, require more extensive work, and may disrupt your daily routine for a while.

Factors to Consider

So, which option should you choose? Deciding whether to replace or repair your shower mainly depends on specific factors, including your shower’s age, condition, and overall shape. It’s worth noting that when you keep repairing an old shower, it may end up costing you more money than simply getting a new one.

Additionally, if you opt for shower replacement, the benefits you gain, like better water efficiency, advanced features, and a higher resale value, may outweigh the extra costs incurred. If your shower has served you for decades, a complete replacement with new technologies could be the bare necessity for your comfort and safety.

DIY vs Professional Repair or Replacement

Before deciding between DIY and professional repair or replacement, you need to consider several important factors.

Firstly, the complexity of the repair or replacement is crucial to determine; some repairs may only require basic skills, tools, and knowledge, while others may be more complicated and require specialized expertise.

Secondly, think about the safety risks that come with DIY repairs or replacements. If you’re not familiar with certain tools or procedures, you could cause more damage or even injure yourself.

Finally, consider the availability and cost of replacement parts or professional services. If the parts or services are hard to come by or too expensive, it may not be worth the effort to attempt a DIY repair.

Pros and Cons of DIY Repair or Replacement

If you have the necessary skills, tools, and time, DIY repairs or replacements have their advantages. Firstly, DIY repairs can be cost-effective since you only need to purchase the replacement parts or repair materials, saving you on labor costs. Secondly, you have full control over how the repair is done, giving you a sense of accomplishment and empowerment.

However, DIY repairs also have their disadvantages. For one, if you make a mistake, it can be costly to fix or even make the situation worse. Secondly, if your DIY repair doesn’t solve the problem, you may have to call in a professional anyway, leading to more costs and time wasted.

Pros and Cons of Professional Repair or Replacement

Professional repair or replacement services may cost more, but they also have their advantages. Firstly, professional technicians have the necessary skills, tools, and knowledge to do the job right the first time, saving you the time and stress of doing it yourself. Secondly, professional repairs often come with a guarantee or warranty, offering you peace of mind in case the repair doesn’t solve the problem.

However, professional services also have their disadvantages. They can be pricey, and if you have multiple appliances or gadgets that need repair or replacement, they can add up quickly. Secondly, you may have to wait for an appointment and work around the technician’s availability.

When to Choose DIY vs Professional Repair or Replacement

The decision between DIY and professional repair or replacement depends on numerous factors, including your skills, tools, time, budget, and the nature of the repair or replacement. In general, if the repair is simple and doesn’t pose any safety risks, it may be worth attempting yourself. If the repair is complicated or dangerous, or if you’re not sure what you’re doing, it’s best to contact a professional. Similarly, if you have the budget to spare or if the repair is covered by a warranty, a professional repair or replacement may be a better choice.


In the end, it’s up to you to decide between shower repair versus replacement. If you’d rather not go down that road yourself, don’t worry – there are plenty of professionals who can lend a hand.

After all, having a functioning shower is one of the best parts of your day-to-day routine! So don’t let damaged or outdated showers drag you down. Weigh your options and call in experts if needed.

And if you still can’t decide whether to repair or replace your shower, why not take the plunge and call our company, Craig’s Plumbing? Our dedicated team will be more than happy to talk you through it – maybe even give you a few tips and tricks along the way! Now, get out there and start working on that award-winning bathroom oasis!